public school are the better choice
Today's Roundup of Stories– January 31, 2012
Is it wise for sixteen-year-olds to drop out of high school? The answer is almost always no. But requiring them to remain in school five more years is unlikely to produce good results either, since that just means more time in the same education system that already has failed them. Keeping kids in school until they are legally adults may save or create jobs in the field of public education. But that is all it is likely to accomplish. Does the NEA propose that failing 20-year-olds will suddenly become model students because they are sheltered from entering the world of full-time employment just a bit longer?
The dues-paying membership of the Tennessee Education Association has dropped more than 10 percent since the state legislature limited the unions power last year. TEAs rolls have declined from 52,000 to 46,000.
The previous strategy of backing small schools has now been vindicated by the rigorous random-assignment study Gates couldnt wait for. Meanwhile, as part of their newly embraced top-down strategy, the Gates effort to identify the secret formula for effective teaching has failed to bear fruit. The Gates -operated Measuring Effective Teachers Project failed to identify any rubric of observing teachers or any components of those rubrics that were strongly predictive of gains in student learning. And the Gates-backed research supporting the federally-orchestrated Common Core push for national standards and testing has been strikingly lacking in scientific rigor and candor. In short, the Gates Foundation has ditched what rigorous evidence shows worked and is pushing a new strategy completely unsupported by rigorous evidence.
In The Atlantic Online resident cool-kid Kevin Careysings the vouchers-are-all-bad-but-charters-are-all-good song that is the official anthem of the beltway crowd of education reform hipsters. Kevin Carey only uses single examples to make sweeping generalizations so Ill simply outperform him by using multiple counter-examples to disprove his universal and unqualified claims.
